This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.

  • Organic Cacao Brew
  • Organic Cacao Nibs
  • Chocolate
    • All Products
    • Chocolate Bars
    • Bark Chocolate
    • Box Sets & Gift Boxes
    • Chocolate Covered
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Contact Us
    • Store Hours
    • Blog
  • Events
    • Workshops
  • Log in
Captain's Chocolate
  • 0
  • Organic Cacao Brew
  • Organic Cacao Nibs
  • Chocolate
    • All Products
    • Chocolate Bars
    • Bark Chocolate
    • Box Sets & Gift Boxes
    • Chocolate Covered
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Contact Us
    • Store Hours
    • Blog
  • Events
    • Workshops
Captain's Chocolate
Search 0 Cart
Free Shipping on All Continental Orders over $99
Captain's Chocolate

100%

This contains no sugar or sweetener of any sort. It is pure
chocolate. Because we spend lots of time grinding and aging our
chocolate, it is mellower and less bitter than most other 100%
chocolates.

That said, it is still pure chocolate with NO sweetener.
This is not my first choice, but the chocolate flavor lingers in my
mouth and I enjoy it. Some sugar avoiders purchase the 100%
cacao, melt it down and add their own sweeteners like xylitol,
stevia, or monk fruit to it. Just beware if you do this, you have
taken the chocolate out of temper and it will start looking strange if
you don’t use it quickly. The chocolate is still fine to eat, but will
not look beautiful.

↓

Captain's Chocolate

90%

This is a slightly sweetened chocolate. With 90% chocolate
and 10% cane sugar, it has a deep dark chocolate tanginess. If you
are going low carb or just really like dark chocolate give this a try.
If you are a sweet tooth person, go for a lesser concentration.

↕

Captain's Chocolate

75%

This is our middle of the road chocolate. Dark enough for
the dark chocolate lovers and sweet enough for the sweetened
chocolate lovers. Most people are amazed at how mellow our 75%
chocolate is compared to other chocolates of the same percentage.
This is due to the way we process it, but also because we use Costa
Rican beans. Costa Rican beans are rated in the top 5% in the world
for flavor and aroma. The true quality of the beans really comes
through in this blend. If you are a true dark chocolate lover get
this. You will love the richness of the flavor.

↕

Captain's Chocolate

60%

This is our sweetest blend. With 60% chocolate and 40%
cane sugar it hits the spot for sweet chocolate lovers. Even
customers that have said they only eat milk chocolate enjoy our
60%. I used to be a milk chocolate only person. Now, I am a dark
chocolate convert. Again the quality of pure whole bean chocolate
just can’t be beat for true chocolate taste.

↕

Let customers speak for us

from 243 reviews
Uniquely Local

When I first heard about Captain's Chocolate and what Sarah was up to I was definitely interested for The Health Nut Store in Watertown, Wisco. I had a few customers that specifically asked if I carried her bars etc and soon launched her items in the store this past November at our Grand Reopening. We have fan favorites and our dedicated patrons prefer shopping here as we are very grateful to be working with high quality products. Soon we will be having a sampling day~ Thanks Captain's!

The Health Nut
06/18/2026
Kids in the Kitchen: Kids in the Kitchen: My Favorite Grown-Up & Me Tuesday,July 21st (in store only)
Kids in the Kitchen: Kids in the Kitchen: My Favorite Grown-Up & Me Tuesday,July 21st (in store only)

Love this Cacao, I stopped drinking coffee, thisnisuch better!

Michele
06/11/2026
Organic Cacao Brew
Organic Cacao Brew

Chocolate Bar Assortment

Crystal L Barbour
05/31/2026
Chocolate Bar Assortment
Chocolate Bar Assortment

Organic Cacao Nibs

Stacy Tressler
05/23/2026
Organic Cacao Nibs
Organic Cacao Nibs
Celebration

Birthday lunch! Since I haven't baked a cake since 1985...why not chocolate candy rather than chocolate cake!!

Mary Ann Esler
05/23/2026
The Captain's Gift Box
The Captain's Gift Box
Birthdays

I always give Captain’s Chocolate.

Mary Ann Esler
05/11/2026
Captain's Organic Chocolate Bar Bundle 60%, 75% or 90%
Captain's Organic Chocolate Bar Bundle 60%, 75% or 90%
Absolutely wonderful!

Love the new larger size! Now I have to shop for a canister to hold it all. I love that your company has partnered with the farmers to cut out the middlemen and allow the farmers to make more money. It is great because family farms are better than corporate farms. I can’t handle caffeine anymore and have never liked the taste of coffee ( I do love the smell though) so the cacao has been wonderful for my daily routine. I have noticed that I don’t get sluggish in the middle of the afternoon.
The chocolate thank you is nice too.

Elizabeth Merry
04/25/2026
Organic Cacao Brew
Organic Cacao Brew
Drink Organic Cacao Brew instead of Coffee

Love Organic Cacao Brew. Drink it everyday as a coffee replacement. Tastes like hot chocolate with cream added.

Reba Parkinson
04/24/2026
Organic Cacao Brew
Organic Cacao Brew
Happy to find Organic Cacao

I have brewed cacao for several years, off and on, as an alternative to coffee. A couple years ago the company I was buying from stopped providing organic options, and after a while I stopped purchasing it altogether.

When I found Captain’s chocolate, I was thrilled that they have high quality organic cacao, and even more happy with their partnership with the farmers in Costa Rica.

The flavor of the cacao is top notch… everything I would expect from a single origin chocolate. I love having brewed cacao again as a supplement to my morning routine, and an alternative to coffee when I need to dial back on the caffeine.

Forrest Cramer
04/23/2026
Organic Cacao Brew
Organic Cacao Brew
Devastatingly Delicious!!!

I recommend this brand for a fine gift for the chocolate lover in your life. That includes yourself! This chocolate is silky smooth and delicious 🤗 Pride in the product is evident in the ingredients. Expensive but worth the splurge for special occasions.

Kim Tyssowski
04/20/2026
Organic Deliciously Dark Chocolate Bar (40g)
Organic Deliciously Dark Chocolate Bar (40g)
super happy

I honestly love this stuff!! I was hesitant at first because I was used to a competitors brand that has a stronger taste. But now when I tried their cacao, it can't even drink it anymore. I can tell the different of a more natural product in Captain's. Even just cleaning the beans after... they expand and have no chemicals... versus the competition that it sticks together like glue. I am so glad I bought this.... I am hooked!!

Lawrence
04/19/2026
Organic Cacao Brew
Organic Cacao Brew

My favorite product. Fresh taste

G.L.
04/19/2026
Chocolate Covered Hazelnuts
Chocolate Covered Hazelnuts

Delicious

G.L.
04/19/2026
Organic Coffee Dark Chocolate Box Set (12pc)
Organic Coffee Dark Chocolate Box Set (12pc)
Great Taste!

Finally a 90% with different flavors!

Healthy Dude
04/15/2026
Organic 90% Dark Chocolate Bars Variety
Organic 90% Dark Chocolate Bars Variety
100 percent cacoa

What a blessing having no sugar and pure cacao . Try mixing it with some organic dates it is my snack when I need something sweet.

Janet Petersen
04/14/2026
Organic Block Chocolate 100% Cacao
Organic Block Chocolate 100% Cacao

Subscribe for discounts, delicious recipes, new product updates, and more!

  • Search
  • Hours of Operation
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Book a Chocolate Experience!

Captain's Chocolate
N2225 Cty Road EE
Neosho, WI 53059
(262) 292-9256

Select Country:

  • Afghanistan (AFN ؋)
  • Åland Islands (EUR €)
  • Albania (ALL L)
  • Algeria (DZD د.ج)
  • Andorra (EUR €)
  • Angola (USD $)
  • Anguilla (XCD $)
  • Antigua & Barbuda (XCD $)
  • Argentina (USD $)
  • Armenia (AMD դր.)
  • Aruba (AWG ƒ)
  • Ascension Island (SHP £)
  • Australia (AUD $)
  • Austria (EUR €)
  • Azerbaijan (AZN ₼)
  • Bahamas (BSD $)
  • Bahrain (USD $)
  • Bangladesh (BDT ৳)
  • Barbados (BBD $)
  • Belarus (USD $)
  • Belgium (EUR €)
  • Belize (BZD $)
  • Benin (XOF Fr)
  • Bermuda (USD $)
  • Bhutan (USD $)
  • Bolivia (BOB Bs.)
  • Bosnia & Herzegovina (BAM КМ)
  • Botswana (BWP P)
  • Brazil (USD $)
  • British Indian Ocean Territory (USD $)
  • British Virgin Islands (USD $)
  • Brunei (BND $)
  • Bulgaria (EUR €)
  • Burkina Faso (XOF Fr)
  • Burundi (BIF Fr)
  • Cambodia (KHR ៛)
  • Cameroon (XAF CFA)
  • Canada (CAD $)
  • Cape Verde (CVE $)
  • Caribbean Netherlands (USD $)
  • Cayman Islands (KYD $)
  • Central African Republic (XAF CFA)
  • Chad (XAF CFA)
  • Chile (USD $)
  • China (CNY ¥)
  • Christmas Island (AUD $)
  • Cocos (Keeling) Islands (AUD $)
  • Colombia (USD $)
  • Comoros (KMF Fr)
  • Congo - Brazzaville (XAF CFA)
  • Congo - Kinshasa (CDF Fr)
  • Cook Islands (NZD $)
  • Costa Rica (CRC ₡)
  • Côte d’Ivoire (XOF Fr)
  • Croatia (EUR €)
  • Curaçao (ANG ƒ)
  • Cyprus (EUR €)
  • Czechia (CZK Kč)
  • Denmark (DKK kr.)
  • Djibouti (DJF Fdj)
  • Dominica (XCD $)
  • Dominican Republic (DOP $)
  • Ecuador (USD $)
  • Egypt (EGP ج.م)
  • El Salvador (USD $)
  • Equatorial Guinea (XAF CFA)
  • Eritrea (USD $)
  • Estonia (EUR €)
  • Eswatini (USD $)
  • Ethiopia (ETB Br)
  • Falkland Islands (FKP £)
  • Faroe Islands (DKK kr.)
  • Fiji (FJD $)
  • Finland (EUR €)
  • France (EUR €)
  • French Guiana (EUR €)
  • French Polynesia (XPF Fr)
  • French Southern Territories (EUR €)
  • Gabon (XOF Fr)
  • Gambia (GMD D)
  • Georgia (USD $)
  • Germany (EUR €)
  • Ghana (USD $)
  • Gibraltar (GBP £)
  • Greece (EUR €)
  • Greenland (DKK kr.)
  • Grenada (XCD $)
  • Guadeloupe (EUR €)
  • Guatemala (GTQ Q)
  • Guernsey (GBP £)
  • Guinea (GNF Fr)
  • Guinea-Bissau (XOF Fr)
  • Guyana (GYD $)
  • Haiti (USD $)
  • Honduras (HNL L)
  • Hong Kong SAR (HKD $)
  • Hungary (HUF Ft)
  • Iceland (ISK kr)
  • India (INR ₹)
  • Indonesia (IDR Rp)
  • Iraq (USD $)
  • Ireland (EUR €)
  • Isle of Man (GBP £)
  • Israel (ILS ₪)
  • Italy (EUR €)
  • Jamaica (JMD $)
  • Japan (JPY ¥)
  • Jersey (USD $)
  • Jordan (USD $)
  • Kazakhstan (KZT ₸)
  • Kenya (KES KSh)
  • Kiribati (USD $)
  • Kosovo (EUR €)
  • Kuwait (USD $)
  • Kyrgyzstan (KGS som)
  • Laos (LAK ₭)
  • Latvia (EUR €)
  • Lebanon (LBP ل.ل)
  • Lesotho (USD $)
  • Liberia (USD $)
  • Libya (USD $)
  • Liechtenstein (CHF CHF)
  • Lithuania (EUR €)
  • Luxembourg (EUR €)
  • Macao SAR (MOP P)
  • Madagascar (USD $)
  • Malawi (MWK MK)
  • Malaysia (MYR RM)
  • Maldives (MVR MVR)
  • Mali (XOF Fr)
  • Malta (EUR €)
  • Martinique (EUR €)
  • Mauritania (USD $)
  • Mauritius (MUR ₨)
  • Mayotte (EUR €)
  • Mexico (USD $)
  • Moldova (MDL L)
  • Monaco (EUR €)
  • Mongolia (MNT ₮)
  • Montenegro (EUR €)
  • Montserrat (XCD $)
  • Morocco (MAD د.م.)
  • Mozambique (USD $)
  • Myanmar (Burma) (MMK K)
  • Namibia (USD $)
  • Nauru (AUD $)
  • Nepal (NPR Rs.)
  • Netherlands (EUR €)
  • New Caledonia (XPF Fr)
  • New Zealand (NZD $)
  • Nicaragua (NIO C$)
  • Niger (XOF Fr)
  • Nigeria (NGN ₦)
  • Niue (NZD $)
  • Norfolk Island (AUD $)
  • North Macedonia (MKD ден)
  • Norway (USD $)
  • Oman (USD $)
  • Pakistan (PKR ₨)
  • Palestinian Territories (ILS ₪)
  • Panama (USD $)
  • Papua New Guinea (PGK K)
  • Paraguay (PYG ₲)
  • Peru (PEN S/)
  • Philippines (PHP ₱)
  • Pitcairn Islands (NZD $)
  • Poland (PLN zł)
  • Portugal (EUR €)
  • Qatar (QAR ر.ق)
  • Réunion (EUR €)
  • Romania (RON Lei)
  • Russia (USD $)
  • Rwanda (RWF FRw)
  • Samoa (WST T)
  • San Marino (EUR €)
  • São Tomé & Príncipe (STD Db)
  • Saudi Arabia (SAR ر.س)
  • Senegal (XOF Fr)
  • Serbia (RSD РСД)
  • Seychelles (USD $)
  • Sierra Leone (SLL Le)
  • Singapore (SGD $)
  • Sint Maarten (ANG ƒ)
  • Slovakia (EUR €)
  • Slovenia (EUR €)
  • Solomon Islands (SBD $)
  • Somalia (USD $)
  • South Africa (USD $)
  • South Georgia & South Sandwich Islands (GBP £)
  • South Korea (KRW ₩)
  • South Sudan (USD $)
  • Spain (EUR €)
  • Sri Lanka (LKR ₨)
  • St. Barthélemy (EUR €)
  • St. Helena (SHP £)
  • St. Kitts & Nevis (XCD $)
  • St. Lucia (XCD $)
  • St. Martin (EUR €)
  • St. Pierre & Miquelon (EUR €)
  • St. Vincent & Grenadines (XCD $)
  • Sudan (USD $)
  • Suriname (USD $)
  • Svalbard & Jan Mayen (USD $)
  • Sweden (SEK kr)
  • Switzerland (CHF CHF)
  • Taiwan (TWD $)
  • Tajikistan (TJS ЅМ)
  • Tanzania (TZS Sh)
  • Thailand (THB ฿)
  • Timor-Leste (USD $)
  • Togo (XOF Fr)
  • Tokelau (NZD $)
  • Tonga (TOP T$)
  • Trinidad & Tobago (TTD $)
  • Tristan da Cunha (GBP £)
  • Tunisia (USD $)
  • Türkiye (USD $)
  • Turkmenistan (USD $)
  • Turks & Caicos Islands (USD $)
  • Tuvalu (AUD $)
  • U.S. Outlying Islands (USD $)
  • Uganda (UGX USh)
  • Ukraine (UAH ₴)
  • United Arab Emirates (AED د.إ)
  • United Kingdom (GBP £)
  • United States (USD $)
  • Uruguay (UYU $U)
  • Uzbekistan (UZS so'm)
  • Vanuatu (VUV Vt)
  • Vatican City (EUR €)
  • Venezuela (USD $)
  • Vietnam (VND ₫)
  • Wallis & Futuna (XPF Fr)
  • Western Sahara (MAD د.م.)
  • Yemen (YER ﷼)
  • Zambia (USD $)
  • Zimbabwe (USD $)
    American Express Apple Pay Bancontact Diners Club Discover Google Pay iDEAL Wero Mastercard PayPal Shop Pay Visa
  • © 2026, Captain's Chocolate
  • Powered by Shopify