This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.

  • Shop
    • All Products
    • All Collections
      • Workshops
      • Bars
      • Gift Boxes & Sets
      • Bark
      • Chocolate Covered
      • Vegan
      • Cacao Brew & Accessories
    • Organic Cacao Brew
    • Organic Cacao Nibs
    • Chocolate Bars
    • Bark Chocolate
    • Gift Collection
    • Chocolate Covered
    • Events
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Contact Us
    • Store Hours
  • Blog
  • Log in
  • Shop
    • All Products
    • All Collections
      • Workshops
      • Bars
      • Gift Boxes & Sets
      • Bark
      • Chocolate Covered
      • Vegan
      • Cacao Brew & Accessories
    • Organic Cacao Brew
    • Organic Cacao Nibs
    • Chocolate Bars
    • Bark Chocolate
    • Gift Collection
    • Chocolate Covered
    • Events
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Contact Us
    • Store Hours
  • Blog
Captain's Chocolate
  • 0
Captain's Chocolate
Search 0 Cart
Free Shipping on All Continental Orders over $74
Captain's Chocolate

100%

This contains no sugar or sweetener of any sort. It is pure
chocolate. Because we spend lots of time grinding and aging our
chocolate, it is mellower and less bitter than most other 100%
chocolates.

That said, it is still pure chocolate with NO sweetener.
This is not my first choice, but the chocolate flavor lingers in my
mouth and I enjoy it. Some sugar avoiders purchase the 100%
cacao, melt it down and add their own sweeteners like xylitol,
stevia, or monk fruit to it. Just beware if you do this, you have
taken the chocolate out of temper and it will start looking strange if
you don’t use it quickly. The chocolate is still fine to eat, but will
not look beautiful.

↓

Captain's Chocolate

90%

This is a slightly sweetened chocolate. With 90% chocolate
and 10% cane sugar, it has a deep dark chocolate tanginess. If you
are going low carb or just really like dark chocolate give this a try.
If you are a sweet tooth person, go for a lesser concentration.

↕

Captain's Chocolate

75%

This is our middle of the road chocolate. Dark enough for
the dark chocolate lovers and sweet enough for the sweetened
chocolate lovers. Most people are amazed at how mellow our 75%
chocolate is compared to other chocolates of the same percentage.
This is due to the way we process it, but also because we use Costa
Rican beans. Costa Rican beans are rated in the top 5% in the world
for flavor and aroma. The true quality of the beans really comes
through in this blend. If you are a true dark chocolate lover get
this. You will love the richness of the flavor.

↕

Captain's Chocolate

60%

This is our sweetest blend. With 60% chocolate and 40%
cane sugar it hits the spot for sweet chocolate lovers. Even
customers that have said they only eat milk chocolate enjoy our
60%. I used to be a milk chocolate only person. Now, I am a dark
chocolate convert. Again the quality of pure whole bean chocolate
just can’t be beat for true chocolate taste.

↕

Let customers speak for us

from 209 reviews

Organic Mint Dark Chocolate Box Set (12pc)

Barbara Zammitti
01/27/2026
Organic Mint Dark Chocolate Box Set (12pc)
Organic Mint Dark Chocolate Box Set (12pc)
Yum

Was a real treat although it went pretty fast!

Larry Morris
01/25/2026
Dark Chocolate Covered Vegan Marshmallows
Dark Chocolate Covered Vegan Marshmallows
Excellent chocolate. Our favorite

Has become our go to chocolate. Excellent taste and we love that it sustainably sourced.

Larry Morris
01/19/2026
Organic 90% Dark Chocolate Bars Variety
Organic 90% Dark Chocolate Bars Variety
Excellent!!

Well pleased

Ronald Shivley
01/16/2026
Chocolate Covered Cinnamon Dusted Almonds
Chocolate Covered Cinnamon Dusted Almonds
Gift you don't need to dust

This is the perfect gift for less clutter. Delicious, especially the dark chocolate covered almonds with a dusting of cinnamon. All organic and all healthy!

Mary Ann Esler
01/13/2026
Organic Dark Chocolate Box Set (12pc)
Organic Dark Chocolate Box Set (12pc)
Chocolate blueberries

Everything was delicious.

Maria Uhing D Uhing
01/13/2026
Organic Chocolate Covered Blueberries
Organic Chocolate Covered Blueberries
Great flavors and texture… incredible…

At first bite you will know know these are top notch chocolates… absolutely incredible…

Addison Mock
01/07/2026
Organic Coffee Dark Chocolate Bar (40g)
Organic Coffee Dark Chocolate Bar (40g)
Orgasmic!!!!

Keep the children away! This is adult only chocolate, lol. This is without any doubt the best 60% chocolate I have ever had. Full stop.

If you push away from real chocolate because you think it’s as bitter as a winter gale, you have to take a virtual trip to Costa Rico via Wisconsin and make the gustatory discovery of your life!

Marc
01/07/2026
Organic Salted Caramel Dark Chocolate Bar (40g)
Organic Salted Caramel Dark Chocolate Bar (40g)
Very dark, creamy

Very rich dark flavor. Creamy and smooth- would like stronger peppermint flavor however

Johanna
01/06/2026
Organic Midnight Mint Dark Chocolate Bar (40g)
Organic Midnight Mint Dark Chocolate Bar (40g)
Great Cacao Brew!

I’ve been trying different versions/companies of cacao for a while now, and have to say that Captain’s Chocolate has ended my search. I love the cacao brew they offer. They are the perfect find! If you are a cacao brew fan, then this is the place for you.

Shannon
01/05/2026
Organic Cacao Brew
Organic Cacao Brew

Fantastic chocolate. Great Service. Thank you and Happy New Year!

Maria Uhing D Uhing
01/03/2026
Organic Cacao Nibs
Organic Cacao Nibs
Excellent chocolate

Bought some chocolate for my son and his partner. It was a big hit! Excellent service as well.

Rachelle Frank
12/29/2025
Organic Cacao Brew
Organic Cacao Brew
Great company offering a great taste

I had my full dealing with Crio Bru and was looking for someone who was responsible and responsive. Nicely ground (I use 60 cc for 12), rich flavor, no caffeine side effects, reasonable prices, and great shipping.

Look no further

Marc
12/18/2025
Organic Cacao Brew
Organic Cacao Brew
Cacao Brew Bliss!

So happy to have found you! The taste is rich and chocolaty. My favorite way is to add a tablespoon of ghee, then whirl in the blender, which develops a frothy creamy top...so delicious! I will be reordering.

Cindy B.
12/18/2025
Organic Cacao Brew
Organic Cacao Brew
Deliciously decadent.

Love the cinnamon dusting over the dark chocolate. Really adds a nice twist to something already delicious.

G.E.
12/14/2025
Chocolate Covered Cinnamon Dusted Almonds
Chocolate Covered Cinnamon Dusted Almonds

Subscribe for discounts, delicious recipes, new product updates, and more!

  • Search
  • Hours of Operation
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Book a Chocolate Experience!

Captain's Chocolate
N2225 Cty Road EE
Neosho, WI 53059
(262) 292-9256

Select Country:

  • Afghanistan (AFN ؋)
  • Åland Islands (EUR €)
  • Albania (ALL L)
  • Algeria (DZD د.ج)
  • Andorra (EUR €)
  • Angola (USD $)
  • Anguilla (XCD $)
  • Antigua & Barbuda (XCD $)
  • Argentina (USD $)
  • Armenia (AMD դր.)
  • Aruba (AWG ƒ)
  • Ascension Island (SHP £)
  • Australia (AUD $)
  • Austria (EUR €)
  • Azerbaijan (AZN ₼)
  • Bahamas (BSD $)
  • Bahrain (USD $)
  • Bangladesh (BDT ৳)
  • Barbados (BBD $)
  • Belarus (USD $)
  • Belgium (EUR €)
  • Belize (BZD $)
  • Benin (XOF Fr)
  • Bermuda (USD $)
  • Bhutan (USD $)
  • Bolivia (BOB Bs.)
  • Bosnia & Herzegovina (BAM КМ)
  • Botswana (BWP P)
  • Brazil (USD $)
  • British Indian Ocean Territory (USD $)
  • British Virgin Islands (USD $)
  • Brunei (BND $)
  • Bulgaria (EUR €)
  • Burkina Faso (XOF Fr)
  • Burundi (BIF Fr)
  • Cambodia (KHR ៛)
  • Cameroon (XAF CFA)
  • Canada (CAD $)
  • Cape Verde (CVE $)
  • Caribbean Netherlands (USD $)
  • Cayman Islands (KYD $)
  • Central African Republic (XAF CFA)
  • Chad (XAF CFA)
  • Chile (USD $)
  • China (CNY ¥)
  • Christmas Island (AUD $)
  • Cocos (Keeling) Islands (AUD $)
  • Colombia (USD $)
  • Comoros (KMF Fr)
  • Congo - Brazzaville (XAF CFA)
  • Congo - Kinshasa (CDF Fr)
  • Cook Islands (NZD $)
  • Costa Rica (CRC ₡)
  • Côte d’Ivoire (XOF Fr)
  • Croatia (EUR €)
  • Curaçao (ANG ƒ)
  • Cyprus (EUR €)
  • Czechia (CZK Kč)
  • Denmark (DKK kr.)
  • Djibouti (DJF Fdj)
  • Dominica (XCD $)
  • Dominican Republic (DOP $)
  • Ecuador (USD $)
  • Egypt (EGP ج.م)
  • El Salvador (USD $)
  • Equatorial Guinea (XAF CFA)
  • Eritrea (USD $)
  • Estonia (EUR €)
  • Eswatini (USD $)
  • Ethiopia (ETB Br)
  • Falkland Islands (FKP £)
  • Faroe Islands (DKK kr.)
  • Fiji (FJD $)
  • Finland (EUR €)
  • France (EUR €)
  • French Guiana (EUR €)
  • French Polynesia (XPF Fr)
  • French Southern Territories (EUR €)
  • Gabon (XOF Fr)
  • Gambia (GMD D)
  • Georgia (USD $)
  • Germany (EUR €)
  • Ghana (USD $)
  • Gibraltar (GBP £)
  • Greece (EUR €)
  • Greenland (DKK kr.)
  • Grenada (XCD $)
  • Guadeloupe (EUR €)
  • Guatemala (GTQ Q)
  • Guernsey (GBP £)
  • Guinea (GNF Fr)
  • Guinea-Bissau (XOF Fr)
  • Guyana (GYD $)
  • Haiti (USD $)
  • Honduras (HNL L)
  • Hong Kong SAR (HKD $)
  • Hungary (HUF Ft)
  • Iceland (ISK kr)
  • India (INR ₹)
  • Indonesia (IDR Rp)
  • Iraq (USD $)
  • Ireland (EUR €)
  • Isle of Man (GBP £)
  • Israel (ILS ₪)
  • Italy (EUR €)
  • Jamaica (JMD $)
  • Japan (JPY ¥)
  • Jersey (USD $)
  • Jordan (USD $)
  • Kazakhstan (KZT ₸)
  • Kenya (KES KSh)
  • Kiribati (USD $)
  • Kosovo (EUR €)
  • Kuwait (USD $)
  • Kyrgyzstan (KGS som)
  • Laos (LAK ₭)
  • Latvia (EUR €)
  • Lebanon (LBP ل.ل)
  • Lesotho (USD $)
  • Liberia (USD $)
  • Libya (USD $)
  • Liechtenstein (CHF CHF)
  • Lithuania (EUR €)
  • Luxembourg (EUR €)
  • Macao SAR (MOP P)
  • Madagascar (USD $)
  • Malawi (MWK MK)
  • Malaysia (MYR RM)
  • Maldives (MVR MVR)
  • Mali (XOF Fr)
  • Malta (EUR €)
  • Martinique (EUR €)
  • Mauritania (USD $)
  • Mauritius (MUR ₨)
  • Mayotte (EUR €)
  • Mexico (USD $)
  • Moldova (MDL L)
  • Monaco (EUR €)
  • Mongolia (MNT ₮)
  • Montenegro (EUR €)
  • Montserrat (XCD $)
  • Morocco (MAD د.م.)
  • Mozambique (USD $)
  • Myanmar (Burma) (MMK K)
  • Namibia (USD $)
  • Nauru (AUD $)
  • Nepal (NPR Rs.)
  • Netherlands (EUR €)
  • New Caledonia (XPF Fr)
  • New Zealand (NZD $)
  • Nicaragua (NIO C$)
  • Niger (XOF Fr)
  • Nigeria (NGN ₦)
  • Niue (NZD $)
  • Norfolk Island (AUD $)
  • North Macedonia (MKD ден)
  • Norway (USD $)
  • Oman (USD $)
  • Pakistan (PKR ₨)
  • Palestinian Territories (ILS ₪)
  • Panama (USD $)
  • Papua New Guinea (PGK K)
  • Paraguay (PYG ₲)
  • Peru (PEN S/)
  • Philippines (PHP ₱)
  • Pitcairn Islands (NZD $)
  • Poland (PLN zł)
  • Portugal (EUR €)
  • Qatar (QAR ر.ق)
  • Réunion (EUR €)
  • Romania (RON Lei)
  • Russia (USD $)
  • Rwanda (RWF FRw)
  • Samoa (WST T)
  • San Marino (EUR €)
  • São Tomé & Príncipe (STD Db)
  • Saudi Arabia (SAR ر.س)
  • Senegal (XOF Fr)
  • Serbia (RSD РСД)
  • Seychelles (USD $)
  • Sierra Leone (SLL Le)
  • Singapore (SGD $)
  • Sint Maarten (ANG ƒ)
  • Slovakia (EUR €)
  • Slovenia (EUR €)
  • Solomon Islands (SBD $)
  • Somalia (USD $)
  • South Africa (USD $)
  • South Georgia & South Sandwich Islands (GBP £)
  • South Korea (KRW ₩)
  • South Sudan (USD $)
  • Spain (EUR €)
  • Sri Lanka (LKR ₨)
  • St. Barthélemy (EUR €)
  • St. Helena (SHP £)
  • St. Kitts & Nevis (XCD $)
  • St. Lucia (XCD $)
  • St. Martin (EUR €)
  • St. Pierre & Miquelon (EUR €)
  • St. Vincent & Grenadines (XCD $)
  • Sudan (USD $)
  • Suriname (USD $)
  • Svalbard & Jan Mayen (USD $)
  • Sweden (SEK kr)
  • Switzerland (CHF CHF)
  • Taiwan (TWD $)
  • Tajikistan (TJS ЅМ)
  • Tanzania (TZS Sh)
  • Thailand (THB ฿)
  • Timor-Leste (USD $)
  • Togo (XOF Fr)
  • Tokelau (NZD $)
  • Tonga (TOP T$)
  • Trinidad & Tobago (TTD $)
  • Tristan da Cunha (GBP £)
  • Tunisia (USD $)
  • Türkiye (USD $)
  • Turkmenistan (USD $)
  • Turks & Caicos Islands (USD $)
  • Tuvalu (AUD $)
  • U.S. Outlying Islands (USD $)
  • Uganda (UGX USh)
  • Ukraine (UAH ₴)
  • United Arab Emirates (AED د.إ)
  • United Kingdom (GBP £)
  • United States (USD $)
  • Uruguay (UYU $U)
  • Uzbekistan (UZS so'm)
  • Vanuatu (VUV Vt)
  • Vatican City (EUR €)
  • Venezuela (USD $)
  • Vietnam (VND ₫)
  • Wallis & Futuna (XPF Fr)
  • Western Sahara (MAD د.م.)
  • Yemen (YER ﷼)
  • Zambia (USD $)
  • Zimbabwe (USD $)
    American Express Apple Pay Bancontact Diners Club Discover Google Pay iDEAL Mastercard PayPal Shop Pay Visa
  • © 2026, Captain's Chocolate
  • Powered by Shopify